MusicDish e-Journal - December 18, 2014
MusicDish Advertising Network
» HOME » INSIDER SCOOP » CAREER TIPS » MUSIC SPOTLIGHT » MUSICDISH*CHINA
» INDUSTRY INTERVIEWS » NEWS BEAT » DIGITAL SKOOL » OPEN REVIEW » MUSICDISH EDELWEISS
Search MusicDish e-Journal (Advanced)
Subscribe To MusicDish e-Journal
About | Contact | Advertise | RSS | Submit Article | Submit News | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution
Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network

The New World
While Napster May Disappear, File-Sharing Will Live On...
By Anonymous
(more articles from this author)
2001-03-25
Comment | Email | Print | RSS

Napster may disappear, but the business of file sharing among members of the musical audience will not. It is well known that the various distributed networks like Gnutella and Freenet will create the same opportunity for users that they have enjoyed with Napster. If Napster falls, it is merely a matter of time before the use of these networks becomes easy enough for them to gain wide acceptance by the public. And when that occurs, the Napster community will continue its file sharing there.

Further, technology is developing at an ever-increasing rate. If you believe Ray Kurzweil's conclusions in his book "The Age of the Spiritual Machine" - and I see no reason to doubt the general thrust of his conclusions - it will soon be the case that when a work gets disseminated to any non-private group, the work will immediately become freely available to the public. There will almost always be frictions, of course, as in most processes, but the frictions will be relatively small and unimportant.

The argument that shows this last point is as follows: even if all material is watermarked and encrypted, however strongly, it must ultimately come out a loudspeaker in pristine form, and from there it can be recorded without loss of quality (at least to the human ear) and converted to mp3 or other digital form without any watermark or encryption encumbrance.

Listening to music is similar to downloading another's experience into your own mind, like reading Schopenhauer. This downloading will, like virtual sex, become ever more available and ever more efficient and ever more "real" (whatever that might mean) and stimulating.

For music, these developments lead to some inevitable consequences and some interesting questions. One inevitable consequence is that the vast library of music that has been disseminated through Napster file sharing is an essentially free catalogue that will be forever available to anyone, regardless of what happens to Napster. Another inevitable consequence is that, sooner or later, the digital sale of any music to the public will automatically make that music available for free to the public.

The interesting questions, some answers, and some observations relevant to the more inscrutable questions, are:

How will musicians be paid?

1- Musicians will of course always be paid for live performances, but reproductions of these live performances will become immediately freely available

2- The incentive to pay for a live performance will be to witness its spontaneity, the mistakes, embellishments, new music, variations of previous pieces, to be in the presence of creation and inspiration, etc. -- the same incentive jazz fans have to attend performances of the same group night after night.

3- The notion of compensation will change - artistic expression, fame, the emotional release of performance, and personal, emotional and sexual contacts will be the driving forces

4- The Stephen King model is probably the only reasonable model: you will get to hear more only if you continue to pay. Live performance will be available to you anywhere in the world. You will pay for a live performance either by the byte, or minute, etc.

If the development causes the income to musicians to decline, will the quality of music suffer?

Related questions are:

1) Will increased distribution possibilities outweigh reduced earnings and lead to higher quality music, or will reduced earnings cause a decline in the quality of music?

2) Will the earnings of musicians be commensurate with their earnings today? An artist like Bob Dylan, for instance, gets about 2 cents per dollar spent by the end-consumer. If the delivery mechanisms are costless or minimal compared to previously (CD's, etc), his percentage of dollars spent must rise. Will the increased percentage of dollars spent compensate for the fewer dollars spent on such an artist's music?

Some observations that bear on these questions:

- Few musicians embark on a career in music to make money. Someone with the talent to make good music probably could apply that same talent elsewhere and be much more assured of a good income.

- Many musicians gravitate into commercial music because it can provide a good income. Commercial music is not the object of much (if any) file sharing, and so it probably will not suffer and will remain an opportunity for those musicians who are so disposed.

- For those musicians fortunate enough to experience great popularity, fame and huge financial success, the thrill of catapulting into the stratosphere of audience popularity probably generates an excitement in them that is also brought to their music. To the extent that this excitement is generated by the financial success, this excitement may diminish.

- The selection process by which musicians of originality and talent will become more efficient. Musicians who might have a large but dispersed audience will have access to, and will be rewarded by, that audience. And musicians who might otherwise not pursue their music further will be encouraged to do so, adding talent to the pool.

How will distributors and the "industry" be paid?

The music industry performs various services:
1-Discovery of artists
2-Development of artists
3-Promotion of artists and music
4-Production of 1st hand (live performance) experiences
5-Manufacture of media for 2nd hand (media delivered) experiences.
6-Sales of media

The prospects of each service are:

1- The service of discovery will achieve greater importance due to the increasing numbers of musicians and varieties of music.

2- Development of artists will continue to be important, although less important than in the past because of the existence of technology that helps musicians create and implement their creations. Producers will be less important, due to the proliferation of studio equipment and the automation of many producer functions.

3- Promotion of artists and music will continue to be important, possibly even more important than today.

4- Production of 1st hand (live) performances will maintain its present importance, at least.

Services 5 and 6 will be available at extremely low cost (money and time) to the music creators. Very little will be paid for these services.

The prospects for those parts of the music industry, which exploit time and space inefficiencies are thus grim. This could of course have been deduced merely from the general principle that such inefficiencies are being eliminated by the increased technological sophistication of the machinery available to the public.

Note that many of the same considerations apply equally to visual media, in particular to film, for which the prospects appear to be quite a bit grimmer. The film industry performs essentially the same services as those listed above. However, creating a film is a much more collaborative and costly enterprise, and services 5 and 6 earn a much greater proportion of the consumer dollar spent than they do in music.


Home » Insider Scoop » The New World
Permalink:http://www.musicdish.com/mag/?id=3404
Email |Print |Comment |RSS

back | top


MusicDish Advertising Network

Insider Scoop

» CMA Gives Snapshot Into Music Discovery Behavior

» Spotify Overtakes iTunes in Europe for Kobalt

» CIAM Congress Meets in Nashville to Discuss Music Copyright in the Digital Age

» Over 90% Of Adults Support The Provision Of Music In Schools

» WIN Calls YouTube's Decisions "A Grave Error of Commercial Judgement"

Insider Scoop Directory



» [2014-11-20] BMG Signs Worldwide Rights Management Deal With Chinese Music Company Giant Jump; BMG Will Exclusively Manage All Giant Jump's Recording And Music Publishing Rights, Both Domestically And Internationally

» [2014-11-20] CMA Gives Snapshot Into Music Discovery Behavior; While AM/FM Radio Ranked No. 1 As A Music Source, Streaming Apps And TV Drove Higher Levels Of New Artist Discovery Compared To Radio

» [2014-11-13] How To Manage Your Talent: FIVE Realistic Tips For Success; Talent Agent, Motivational Speaker And Author Of Come Fly With Me... Michael Bublé's Rise To Stardom (A Memoir)

» [2014-11-13] Executive Wach: Villanova University School Of Law, Mozart's Estates Theatre, Universal Music Publishing Group, Music Group, HighVolMusic, New West Records; Villanova University Law Professor; Stage Director Of Don Giovanni Production; UMPG Special Advisor; Music Group Snr Manager, Professional Division For Asia Pacific; HighVolMusic Talent Relations VP; New West Records President

» [2014-11-13] PRS Guitars Amps Up 30 Years Of Manufacturing; The PRS US-made 30th Anniversary Core Model Is A Prime Example Of How Paul And The Craftsmen At PRS Keep Focused On Providing The Best Possible Instruments

» [2014-11-09] Spotify Overtakes ITunes In Europe For Kobalt; Spotify Revenues Surpass ITunes Revenues In Europe By 13% For Kobalt Clients

» [2014-11-06] Incisors Break Through The Dawn With Their Debut Album On Nov. 28; Incisors Break Through The Dawn With Their Debut Album On Nov. 28

» [2014-11-04] The First Chinese Rock Exhibition Launched In Beijing; "Serve The Rock" Exhibition Showcases Rare Collections And Documents From Major Historical Events In The Development Of Chinese Rock

» [2014-11-02] CIAM Congress Meets In Nashville To Discuss Music Copyright In The Digital Age; Fair Trade Music Project Unanimously Adopted To Promote Fair Trade Remuneration For Creators

» [2014-11-01] The Modern Musical Magi Of Beijing; Djang San Will Be Performing At Yugong Yishan On November 26 As Part Of The Dong Dong Music Festival And Convention

» [2014-10-31] World's Most Influential Electronic Music Figureheads Head To Asia; International Music Summit - The Premier Platform For Thought Leadership In Electronic Music - Hits Singapore December 11, 2014

» [2014-10-31] MOCAMIX: DJ Daniel Wang; DJ Daniel Wang Takes Listeners For A Spin On The 90s Chinatown Music Scene, African American Dance Music, And New York's Queer Club Culture
MusicDish Advertising Network

follow MusicDish on
Follow MusicDish on Twitter

Mi2N Music PR

Darrell Cole's "Swahili" Fights Negative African Stereotypes

The Inspiration Behind The Versions Of "Santa Baby" Remakes... Hint, Never Marilyn Monroe!

China Arts Foundation International 2015 New Year's Concert

EVENTIDE UPDATES TIMEFACTOR WITH NEW LOOPER

The New Black 7 Release "God Willin' And The Creek Don't Rise" EP

Indie Act Automatik Eden Garner Rave Reviews For Both EP And Video With Their New Release "Gold To Straw"

Luna Sopor Releases Second Album - Cobalt - Rock

EVENTIDE ANNOUNCES H9 MAX



Websites: Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network
Services: Submit Article | Submit News | Submit Video | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution

Copyright © 1997-2014 MusicDish LLC., all rights reserved.
About MusicDish e-Journal | Contact Us | Advertise | RSS | Internships