MusicDish e-Journal - December 1, 2015
MusicDish Advertising Network
Search MusicDish e-Journal (Advanced)
Subscribe To MusicDish e-Journal
About | Contact | Advertise | RSS | Submit Article | Submit News | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution
Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network

First Blood is Spilled at Record Industry Hearings - The War is On!!!
By Moses Avalon
(more articles from this author)
Comment | Email | Print | RSS

September 26 - Los Angeles. Absent the penalty of perjury, Major Label lawyers testified to a panel of senators in Los Angles that most artists are happy with their recording contracts. The panel, held this past Tuesday, was assembled to entertain arguments as to whether legislation might be necessary to keep major record labels honest when reporting to their artists the amount of money earned on their exclusive record contracts. If enacted, this would be the beginning of government regulation of the music business; a concept that, ironically, artists are initiating.

Tuesday's panel was an informal Joint Hearing of the Senate Committee and Senate Select Committee on the Entertainment Industry. Lawyers and spokespersons from both sides were invited to air their points of view.

Major Labels emphasized that artists, by and large, are "happy with the current system," and based this on the fact that so few artists audit their labels or sue for breach of contract. Meanwhile, artists representatives indicated that this was only the case because many feel intimidated or, in the case of older, more powerful stars, believe that an audit would be useless. The following three points were the center piece of the day's comments:

1) By contract, artists are prohibited from showing royalty statements to third parties. Normally this would not include their managers, lawyers, consultants, or others who could aid them in getting paid, but apparently this is not necessarily the case. Senator Kevin Murray, leading the initiative for artists' rights, claimed the that Cary Sherman, Chief Counsel for the RIAA himself, said to him in an interview, that RIAA members (the major labels) would sue any artist that broke ranks and shared information with the Committee. This claim was rejected by Sherman but supported by others in the room. Don Henley, among them, outwardly dared his record company to sue him for bringing royalty statements to the hearing. He presented his most recent royalty statement for "Hell Freezes Over," which showed the panel that even though his contract called for a no more than a 10% "reserve" on sales of records shipped, Universal Music had held back more than that for eleven pay periods (roughly under three years) and that, even though his contract calls for no free goods in Europe, they had deducted $87,000 in free goods charges to Europe.

2) All boiler plate recording contracts stipulate that manufacturing records are exempt from an audit. Senator Battin took particular interest in this point, wondering how can an artist get an accurate account of sales if they don't know the number of units produced to start with.

3) Even after an artist has gone through the audit and has found recoverable money, they are expected to negotiate a settlement with the record company. Furthermore, their auditors are required to meet with label executives BEFORE they can release findings to their clients (Wow?!?). The net result is that, even after an audit, the artist can expect to get only a fraction of what they are owed. Most would rather not rock the boat.

Another interesting contractual speed-bump is that most contracts regulate who the artist can hire to do the audit. The proverbial "list" seems limited to a small cartel of accountants and financial managers who "understand the way the record business works." The auditor can not be simultaneously auditing the record company for any other artist or any other record company. This makes scheduling the few "qualified accounts" on par with booking Russell Crow for your next motion picture.

Record companies claim that this standard avoids conflicts of interest, makes the audit process cheaper for the artist - as the auditor's time will be minimized - and the company's royalty accounting process will not be held up. But a more likely strategy, as voiced by artist representatives, is that they are trying to deflect auditors from exaggerating their claims, in hopes that the settled-upon amount will be somewhere near what is believed to be owed.

The seasoned artists who testified, admitted that holding out for large advances on second and third albums acts as an enfilade against accounting rip-offs. But it is not always successful. This strategy, however, would exclude artists past their prime and deceased artists, whose money can be kept by the record companies with virtual impunity.

In addition, the common strategy of "renegotiation" after the record is a hit, has meet with opposition as consolidation has caused record companies to get "mean and lean" in the troubled economy. Artists' lawyers have reported that they are having "some tension" with the tradition of getting better terms for their clients after they have a proven hit. In a shocking statement made by Back Street Boy Kevin Richardson, he testified that they have NEVER received a royalty check, and that they only took a large advance after their third hit album in a row failed to earn them a penny in royalties. (Case in point, three albums on a major label is generally about 5 contract years into the term.)

Also, the wife of Lester Chambers, of The Chambers Brothers, claimed to have never received a royalty check, nor an advance, in upwards of 30 years. Ms. Chambers claimed that Columbia told her there were no overseas sales to report because The Chambers Brothers records were never licensed to an overseas distributor. She believed them until she started seeing her product on E-Bay and found 22 different foreign pressings of Chambers Brothers recordings, all by foreign affiliates of her label, Columbia Records, a subsidiary of Sony. Similarly, a member of The Olympics, of the hit "Hully Gully," was present and complained that he found his recording on 94 different compilations world-wide, yet has never received a royalty check.

To defend their actions, record companies hired Linda McLaughlin, an economist, to do a study of record industry profits. She testified that, on the whole, record companies get only 9% of profits while artists get 17%. Upon questioning by Senator Murray, she admitted that when calculating the profits artists earned she was including their publishing money earned from song writing, but when calculating the record company's earnings she broke apart the record sales profits and excluded publishing revenue, even when the artist's account was earning money for both the record and publishing divisions of the same company.

She was also asked to produce comparisons to other industries where royalties are accruable to vendors and furnishers of product. Sighting examples like the book publishing industry, where authors are only required to recoup the actual advance they receive for each book, and not money that is spent on their behalf (i.e.: promotion). She had not included such research in her study. Her study was also only limited to US record labels and not foreign affiliates.

In the afternoon session, representatives of artists steered the conversations towards establishing government regulated penalties for labels clearly trying to defraud their artists. A solution that makes everyone uneasy.

Senators on the panel made it clear that Big Brother peeking in their financial records was probably going to make everybody miserable. But the tone was clear: unless the majors labels come up with a system, whereby they agree to a penalty for under-reporting royalties, then the Senators are likely to introduce a bill making the collection of royalties, especially overseas royalties, a fiduciary duty. This would give the artists who are victimized by chronic under-reporting of royalties legal remedies beyond submitting to a 2-4 year auditing process, which normally costs them $30-$40 thousand dollars before the audit begins (Most contracts expressly prohibit artists from hiring auditors on contingency).

An insider present at the hearing commented, "It was kinda pathetic watching all the major suits try and defend the indefensible... it was clear that the Senators want no part of any legislation, but that they feel it's inevitable if the majors refuse to address any of the artists' concerns."

Research and commentary for this piece was provided by Pat Spear.

Moses Avalon Disclaimer:
This is not news... News is allegedly objective. This is anything but. This is about interpreting the news into information that you can use. The key to predicting the future is in interpreting the past. In real terms, this means understanding how the big players interpret their mistakes and their recent acquisitions.

MusicDish - Music Industry Events

The Moses Avalon Confessions of a Record Producer Workshop

Los Angeles, CA - On November 9th & 10th, 2002, multi-platinum record producer, music industry insider and artists' rights activist, Moses Avalon, will speak candidly at the American Federation of Musicians in a coveted two-day workshop.

Home » Insider Scoop » First Blood is Spilled at Record Industry Hearings - The War is On!!!
Email |Print |Comment |RSS

back | top

MusicDish Advertising Network

Insider Scoop

» Cooking Vinyl's Martin Goldschmidt Calls For Direct Tax Breaks For Music

» Stones Fans Rejoice - 2015 Tour Dates Announced

» ASCAP CEO Elizabeth Matthews Testifies For Senate Judiciary Subcommittee

» Ebook And Music Downloads Stagnate While Mobile Games And Videos See Strong Growth

» Red Bull Music Academy Accepting Applications for Paris Academy

Insider Scoop Directory

» [2015-11-18] BodyMemory New York Launch Reception Flux Factory; LittleE Studio Founder Yi Zhou Creates Of Duplicated Cast Models Of Human Body Parts That Were Transformed Into Accessories

» [2015-11-16] HOT POT - Spicy Little Art Festival; What Happens If 22 Artists From Asia And Europe From A Wide Range Of Art And Design Disciplines Are Collaborating For 14 Weeks?

» [2015-11-16] MusicDish*China Presents Lyric Dubee 'Young & Restless' China Tour; Performing 14 Shows In A Dozen Cities, The China Tour Will Follow Their Participation In Canadian Blast Export - Japan Music Trade Mission

» [2015-11-02] MusicDish And LittleE Studio Launch Crowdfunding Campaign In Support Of BodyMemory; "Sharing The Spirit Of Beijing With New York Through BodyMemory" To Help Fund Beijing-based Artist/designer Yi Zhou's Artist In Residency At New York's Flux Factory

» [2015-11-02] MusicDish*China Brings Japan-Bound Canadian Bands To China; MusicDish*China Has Booked Tours In China For Two Bands Participating In The 4th Music Export Canada Music Mission To Japan

» [2015-10-26] The Jessica Stuart Few China Tour; The Tour Will Bring Their Unique Stage Show Featuring The Japanese Koto To Beijing, Tianjin, Shijiazhuang And Taiyuan

» [2015-10-24] Top 10 Industry Podcast; Must Listen To Podcasts For Musicians

» [2015-10-20] MusicDish*China And AAW Partner On Canadian Guitarist Lyric Dubee China Tour; Following A Tour Of Japan, Lyric Dubee Will Be Performing In A Dozen Cities In China Between November 21 And December 7

» [2015-10-19] Canadian EDM Duo Eagle I Stallian Bring The House Down In Changsha And Wuhan, China; Eagle I Stallian Headlined The UNITY Electronic Music Festival, After Spinning The Electric Underground National Day Party

» [2015-10-18] Modern Sky Festival Brings Chinese Rock To New York; This Year's Lineup Has A Mix Of Acts From Both China And The West, Including China's Most Popular Folk Musician Song Dongye, Indie Rock Bands New Pants And Miserable Faith, British Postpunk Group Gang Of Four And Yoko Ono And Her Band Plastic Ono

» [2015-10-16] The Jessica Stuart Few Brings Masterclasses And Show To Beijing's DDC; Presented By MusicDish*China, The Tour Is Also Supported By Music Portal Kanjian That Is Distributing Her Sophomore Album "Two Sides To Every Story"

» [2015-08-31] China's Indie Music Market And Livehouse Status Quo; An Interview With Meng Yuliang Of Blue Stream Bar And Yuppie Monkey
MusicDish Advertising Network

follow MusicDish on
Follow MusicDish on Twitter

Mi2N Music PR

Whitney Tai Presents "Metamorphosis" Live Dec 20th In NY

Blank-Fest XIX: Back To Help The Homeless For The 19th Year!

From Phoenix To Wisconsin: Midwest Soul Xchange Debut Album

Amaru Releases "The One"

Hear The World Premiere Of The PondHawks New Holiday Song Monday, November 30th, 2015

Kind-Hearted Compassion In Action Presents The ELEVATE GENIUS Concert And Charity Event December 12, 2015 At The Yost Theatre In Santa Ana, CA

Drew Patrick's Debut Single "We Generate A Spark" Set To Ignite Dance Floors Friday

Websites: Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network
Services: Submit Article | Submit News | Submit Video | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution

Copyright © 1997-2015 MusicDish LLC., all rights reserved.
About MusicDish e-Journal | Contact Us | Advertise | RSS | Internships