MusicDish e-Journal - May 27, 2017
MusicDish Advertising Network
» HOME » INSIDER SCOOP » CAREER TIPS » MUSIC SPOTLIGHT » MUSICDISH*CHINA
» INDUSTRY INTERVIEWS » NEWS BEAT » DIGITAL SKOOL » OPEN REVIEW » MUSICDISH EDELWEISS
Search MusicDish e-Journal (Advanced)
Subscribe To MusicDish e-Journal
About | Contact | Advertise | RSS | Submit Article | Submit News | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution
Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network

How Will Artists Ever Get Paid Once Computer Companies Buy Major Labels?
Apple Takes a Byte Out of Vivendi and Chips Its Tooth
By Moses Avalon
(more articles from this author)
2003-05-01
Comment | Email | Print | RSS

It's a garage sale over at Vivendi Universal, the world's largest media conglomerate and owner of UNI distribution, one of the Big Five Record labels.

In a time when nationalism is on the rise and yet 80% of all major labels are owned or distributed by foreign entities, US owned Apple might seem like a welcome buyout of the French's Universal Music (UNI) for a paltry 5 Bill. 

It makes sense. The RIAA has named piracy as the magic bullet of declining sales over the past two years. Well, one way to stop downloading would be to make it unnecessary by giving an entire catalogue of music away whenever you buy a computer. No need to steal the music anymore if it's bundled in the purchase beforehand. It would effectively turn you're computer into a jukebox. Something technology companies have been working towards for about a decade. But is it a good idea in the long run for the people who create the music-- artists and songwriters?

My inside sources are rarely wrong and they tell me that the Apple/UNI deal is practically a non starter. Apple simply doesn't have the scratch. But even if Apple can't make the deal bear fruit, there is always Microsoft or about a dozen other computer companies, like Dell that could.

And what would stop any of these potential acquisitions from bundling a vast music catalogue into the hard drive, much like the Microsoft software you get when you buy a PC? Nothing. And why does this really suck if you are an artist on Universal or one of its fifty-some-odd sub-labels? Well, mainly because it can not be decided how the label will treat this distribution in terms of paying the artist. Artists' and most songwriters' royalties are based on "records sold," not "records distributed." There are several ways a "sale" is calculated in most contracts, but, none of them would provide a clean method of payment for this type of bundling.

For example: is it a "new technology sale?"

No. There is no actual "sale," the records are being deliberately given away.

Is it a "premium?"

It might be, if an indirect relationship existed between the computer buyer and the artist. Premiums are done between two companies, again in furtherance of the sales of records and for promotion of the CD sales as an end product. Computer bundling is better categorized as a support function between two departments of the same conglomerate. So, no, it's not a "premium."

Is it a "license?"

Na. See the above. Besides even if it was a "master license," there is nothing in most contracts that says that the labels have to share licensing money for the master with the artist. (Check your contract)

Is it a "public performance?"

No. There is no streaming or downloading involved. It's bundled.

Is it a "free good?"

Well, labels will try to claim that it is, I'm sure, as this is the easiest way to avoid paying the artist and writers. But this would be a fantasy that most artists' lawyers would agree does not even pass the laugh test. "Free goods" are records given away to instigate further sales. Artists are not paid for these distributions, for obvious reasons. Usually, a proven artist is capable of getting this removed from his contract, as it seems silly to suggest that you need to give away free CDs to get HMV to "take a chance" on an artist that is already selling millions of units. Hit songs bundled in computers will replace normal sales through stores and the internet. Plus, the computer company doing the bundling will be counting on the proven track records of these artists to attract buyers. So it is, if anything, the opposite of a "free good."

Well, we're out of road for royalty paying formats, and there's no check to the artist or songwriter in sight.

This past month at the California Copyright Conference in Los Angeles, some of the industry's top auditors were gathered for a most informative panel, hosted by esteemed LA attorney Cheryl Hodgson (The Kingsmen). I asked this panel, who collectively between them have about 50 years experience in auditing record labels for artists, how this new distribution will yield money for the artist and the songwriter. No one had an answer.

And we may not find out so quickly. The Apple/UNI deal is far from a lock. Their offer of $5 Billion, is laughably low and there are several other contenders: General Electric (GE), Viacom, Liberty Media and Marvin Davis, who has offered $13 billion for 65 percent of Universal's assets.

Why a large military contractor like GE would want to own a record label is too frightening a prospect to contemplate, but Apple's interest is laterally integrated into their current business plan: tying to conquer the world with the iPod (and doing a good job). In the past, however, they've faced issues of copy protection and the fact that ALL of the major labels online music sales sites support only PC platforms. Thus, Apple's acquisition of UNI could actually provide them with a potential monopoly over online music sales to Mac users which represent an estimated 15% of the computer market.

Related MusicDish e-Journal Articles:
» Re: How Will Artists Ever Get Paid Once Computer Companies Buy Major Labels? (2003-06-12)


Home » Insider Scoop » How Will Artists Ever Get Paid Once Computer Companies Buy Major Labels?
Permalink:http://www.musicdish.com/mag/?id=8049
Email |Print |Comment |RSS

back | top


MusicDish Advertising Network

Insider Scoop

» Songwriters Battle For Fair Pay From Music Streaming Services

» Why Do So Many Music Technology Startups Fail?

» New Report Debates Future of Arts & Culture Ticketing

» An Open Letter To President Donald J. Trump

» UK Festival Market Driven By "Super Fans"

Insider Scoop Directory



» [2017-05-27] Deadline Looms - The 22nd Annual USA Songwriting Competition; This Opportunity Is Gone Soon For Songwriters, Deadline To Enter Is May 31st

» [2017-05-27] Amsterdam Dance Event Announces Spotlight On Morocco And Hello DeLaMar, ADE Changes Venue; All Aspects Of Global Electronic Music Culture Will Come Together For The Leading Electronic Music Conference And World's Largest Club Festival

» [2017-05-27] Earl And The Steadies To Play In Seoul For "Back To The Retro" Party; One Of The Top Bassists In Canada, Earl Pereira Is Visiting Korea With Earl And The Steadies

» [2017-05-26] Songwriters Battle For Fair Pay From Music Streaming Services; As CD Sales Dwindle And Digital Streaming Services Grow, Music Publishers And Songwriters Are Paying The Price

» [2017-04-19] ULTRA Worldwide Adds China To Global Calendar; On September 9-10, 2017, ULTRA Will Land In Shanghai For The First Ever Edition Of ULTRA China

» [2017-04-18] A2LiVE Welcomes Eric Reithler-Barros As New Managing Director And CCO; China's EDM Festival Behemoth Eyes Asian Ecosystem Dominance

» [2017-03-16] Jackson Wong Named As Managing Director Of Warner Music China; Wong Will Oversee The Day-to-day Running Of WMG's Beijing Office And Is Also Expected To Expand The Company's Business In Mainland China

» [2017-03-09] Avex Group Rediscovers Mainland China Market; Japan-based Entertainment Management Firm Grants Chinese Platform NetEase Cloud Music An Exclusive License To Its Copyrighted Music

» [2017-03-08] Peermusic And Hamshore Tang Win Lawsuit Against Chinese Label YY; Chinese Court Ruled That YY Should Immediately Cease The Infringement Of The Work's Mechanical, Performance And Digital Rights

» [2017-02-22] Earl & The Steadies Sign With MusicDish For Representation In China; The Band Will Tour Mainland China In May In Support Of The Release Of Their 2016 Album "Love Revolution"

» [2017-02-18] Armada Night - China; The Amsterdam-based Record Label Has Announced The First-ever Armada Night China Tour

» [2017-02-16] NYC's Chinese-American MC Bohan Phoenix Releases New EP 'JALA'; Brooklyn-based, Chinese-transplant Bohan Phoenix Unites Cultures And Expresses His Mixed Identity
MusicDish Advertising Network

follow MusicDish on
Follow MusicDish on Twitter

Mi2N Music PR

GrooveShine New Album - So Cal Acoustic Funk Reggae & Instrumentals

Nick Brodeur Wins Studio Package From ReverbNation

David Longoria, April Diamond, Trent Park, Larissa Lam Head Up White House Event

17-Year-Old Singer/Songwriter Wins Prestigious Music Award In Hawaii

Jah Mason Empowers Women With New Single 'Its Your Life'

Amsterdam Dance Event Announces Spotlight On Morocco And Hello DeLaMar, ADE Changes Venue

Deadline Looms - The 22nd Annual USA Songwriting Competition



Websites: Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network
Services: Submit Article | Submit News | Submit Video | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution

Copyright © 1997-2017 MusicDish LLC., all rights reserved.
About MusicDish e-Journal | Contact Us | Advertise | RSS | Internships