CDT Calls For FTC Action Against Deceptive Download Sites
In a complaint to be filed, the Center for Democracy & Technology called on the Federal Trade Commission to take action against websites deceptively claiming to offer "100% Legal" music and video downloads.
In the complaint, CDT names two sites—Mp3DownloadCity.com and MyMusicInc.com—that claim to offer legal downloads of music and videos in exchange for a subscription fee. In fact, the sites merely point users to free file-sharing software and provide instructions on its use to download unlicensed popular works. CDT's complaint states that these offers are clearly deceptive and therefore a violation of federal law.
A third website, Mp3DownloadHQ.com, agreed on Monday to remove claims to be "100% legal" from its website in response to a letter from CDT. A company called Active Publishing owns the site, along with several others that redirect users to the same location (e.g. MusicNirvana.com, MovieDownloadHQ.com, Mp3-DownloadHQ.com). CDT is reviewing the changes and awaiting a response on whether the changes will apply to all Active Publishing websites and advertising to determine whether to proceed with a complaint against the company.
"We want to see the marketplace for content flourish online," said CDT president Jerry Berman "In order to sustain businesses offering legal downloads, protect the free flow of information online, and avoid broader anti-piracy measures that could harm the Internet itself, we have to go after bad behavior like these deceptive offers."
CDT's complaint explains how "users are led to believe that they are purchasing a license to download and use songs and movies—much like they would on a licensed subscription service like Rhapsody or the new Napster. In fact, users are provided no such license, and if they follow the sites' explicit invitations to download 'movies still in theatres' or music by the Beatles and the Rolling Stones, they may face severe legal liability."
Related News from Mi2N:
» CDT Calls For FTC Action Against Deceptive Download Sites