Research Finds Audible Differences with High-Resolution Audio
Listeners can hear a difference between standard audio and better-than-CD quality, known as high-resolution audio
Listeners can hear a difference between standard audio and better-than-CD quality, known as high-resolution audio, according to a new study published in the June issue of the Journal of the Audio Engineering Society (JAES) by Dr. Joshua Reiss of the Centre for Digital Music, Queen Mary University of London (QMUL).
The meta-study compared data from 18 studies involving 450 participants listening to samples of music in different formats. In total, the studies involved over 12,000 different trials where participants were asked to discriminate between formats. Overall, listeners could distinguish between the formats, especially if they had been trained to hear a difference. This is the first time that formal meta-analysis techniques have been applied to audio engineering research.
In addition to training, the research suggested that careful selection of stimuli, including use of long duration samples, may play an important role in the ability to discriminate. Studies that did not show an ability to discriminate were generally more prone to biases or flaws in their design. Reiss concluded that "the perceived fidelity of an audio recording and playback chain is affected by operating at a resolution higher than the CD standard."
"Audio purists and industry should welcome these findings," said Reiss. "Our study finds high-resolution audio has a small but important advantage in its quality of reproduction over standard audio content. Trained listeners could distinguish between the two formats around sixty percent of the time." Dr. Reiss explained, "One motivation for this research was that people in the audio community endlessly discuss whether the use of high-resolution formats and equipment really makes a difference. Conventional wisdom states that CD quality should be sufficient to capture everything we hear, yet anecdotes abound where individuals claim that hi-res content sounds crisper, or more intense. And people often cherry-pick their favorite study to support whichever side they're on." He continued, "We gathered 80 publications in the field, and analyzed all available data, even asking authors of earlier studies for their original reports from old filing cabinets. We subjected the data to many forms of analysis. The effect was clear, and there were some indicators as to what conditions demonstrate it most effectively. Hopefully, we can now move forward towards identifying how and why we perceive these differences, and better experimental design."
When asked about the type of content for which high-resolution recording and playback most made a difference, Dr. Reiss responded, "The jury is still out. The studies that most showed an effect mainly used jazz and classical music, but this wasn't exclusive. We looked at lots of factors like choice of content and equipment. Results suggested that listeners often needed to listen to each sample for more than 30 seconds, but possible factors were mostly overshadowed by training test subjects in critical listening skills specific to the test, and in general, good experimental design."
Related News from Mi2N:
» Research Finds Audible Differences With High-Resolution Audio
» Rockwood Music Hall First Virtualized Venue To Livestream Concerts In VR
» Baserock Launches Immersive Bass-Frequency Backpack
» HPCmusic Strives to Make Stereo Obsolete - The $100 Billion opportunity
» Music 1 Network Launches New Artist Discovery Platform
» Adva Mobile Fan Engagement Score (ES)
Digital Skool Directory
» [2017-07-05] Music Streaming Service: The Next Frontier For Tesla And Elon Musk; Critical Of Existing Streaming Algorithms And The Quality Of Their Playlists, Elon Musk Promised To Build A Music Service Feature For Tesla Vehicles
» [2017-07-05] Generation Z: Meet The Young Millennials; Teens Value Video Platforms For Music Discovery And Social Engagement, But, As They Develop As Music Consumers, Look To Audio Streaming Services
» [2017-07-04] MusicDish Review: Xi'an Post-Punk Band FAZI 3rd Album "Heart Of Desire"; With Their Usual Blunt Directness, FAZI Once Again Created Music That Awakens The Listeners, Arranged Thick And Deep, Graceful, Velvety Sounds To Adorn This Album
» [2017-07-04] Aloft Hotels And MTV Spotlight Top Asia Pacific Music Talent; Aspiring Musicians Are Invited To Submit Original Songs For A Chance To Win A Mentorship By MTV And US$10,000 To Fund Their Music Journey
» [2017-06-29] Canadian Sounds In China (CSC); July 1 Is Canada's 150th Anniversary And We're Using This Opportunity To A Soft Launch A New Project Called Canadian Sounds In China
» [2017-06-28] QQMusic: From Streaming Service To Integrated Music Content Producer; This Update Pushes QQMusic One Step Closer Towards Becoming An Integrated Music Content Producer
» [2017-06-25] Music Works International Expands Team, Roster And Global Reach; International Booking Agency Builds On Momentum To Push Reach Outward And Upward
» [2017-06-25] BMG Partners With Chinese Social Network Momo; The Deal Will Provide An International Showcase For Emerging Social Media Stars From China
» [2017-06-21] MusicDish Music Releases In China: SLC, HearIM, Tom Ricci, Voodoo Swing; MusicDish*China Has Been Releasing Independent Music To The Major Music Platforms, Reaching Over 90% Of Mainland Chinese Music Listeners
» [2017-06-21] ASCAP And YouTube Reach Multi-Year Agreement For US Performance Rights; The Mutual Goal Of This Agreement Is To Work Together To Ensure That ASCAP Members Get Paid More Fairly And Accurately For The Use Of Their Music On YouTube
» [2017-06-20] Supreme Court Rules Unanimously In Favor Of The Slants; Asian-American Rock Band Wins Long-running Battle With The Trademark Office Over Their Name In A Victory For Free Speech
» [2017-06-18] Longtail Music Provides An Alternative To The On-Demand Algorithm; Live Broadcasts Are Brought To The Forefront To Assist Listeners In Music Discovery
follow MusicDish on