Why Elcomsoft was Acquitted: Orin Kerr
Russia's Elcomsoft may have violated Hollywood's Digital Millennium
Copyright Act with software meant to crack Adobe Systems' eBooks. But a jury
acquitted the company because they believed it didn't mean to break the law,
said the foreman.
"This is sort of the first dent in the DMCA," said ElcomSoft attorney
Joseph Burton. "Up until now, the large publishers have sort of had their
way...(but) I think developers still need to be careful."
Actually, the verdict was no great surprise, particularly after Adobe
retreated from its support of the case against ElcomSoft's Dmitry Sklyarov,
arrested during the Las Vegas Defcon conference after a speech about
So what was it all about, anyway?
In a Volokh Conspiracy piece, George Washington University Law School
associate professor Orin Kerr wrote that jury foreman Dennis Strader said,
in an interview after the verdict, the jurors didn't understand why a
million-dollar company would, "put on their Web page an illegal thing that
would (ruin) their whole business if they were caught".
Kerr also said that according to Strader, the panel found the DMCA itself
confusing, making it easy for jurors to believe that executives from Russia
might not fully understand it.
But, "Why does it matter whether the company meant to violate the law,
you might wonder?" - Kerr asked. And here's his answer.
"The general rule in criminal law is that intent to violate the law
doesn't matter," he says. "As they say, 'ignorance of the law is no excuse.'
However, Congress occasionally limits criminal liability to 'willful'
violations of the law. Although there is some dispute as to what it means to
violate a law 'willfully,' the general rule is that a willful violation
means a violation that is knowingly and purposely in violation of the law
itself. Willful violations are an exception to the usual rule that ignorance
of the law is no excuse: when Congress limits a crime to 'willful'
violations, ignorance of the law is an excuse. The government must prove not
only that the defendant violated the law, but that the defendant knew he was
violating the law.
"The DMCA is one of those laws that limits criminal prosecutions to
willful violations. In other words, Congress only wanted violations of the
DMCA to be criminal when the person actually knew that they were violating
the law and did it anyway. Because the San Jose jury was not convinced
beyond a reasonable doubt that ElcomSoft knew they were violating the law,
the jury acquitted. Why did Congress limit the criminal reach of the DMCA to
'willful' violations, you might wonder? Because these laws are hard, and
Congress didn't want someone to go to jail when it wasn't relatively clear
what the law was. That's the explanation that the courts have offered in the
area of tax law, another complex area of law that allows criminal
prosecutions only for 'willful' violations. Here's an excerpt from the
Supreme Court's decision in Cheek v. United States, 498 U.S. 192 (1991), a
case that interpreted 'willfully' in the context of the federal tax laws:
"The proliferation of statutes and regulations has sometimes made it
difficult for the average citizen to know and comprehend the extent of the
duties and obligations imposed by the tax laws. Congress has accordingly
softened the impact of the common-law presumption by making specific intent
to violate the law an element of certain federal criminal tax offenses.
"Thus, the Court almost 60 years ago interpreted the statutory term
'willfully' as used in the federal criminal tax statutes as carving out an
exception to the traditional rule. This special treatment of criminal tax
offenses is largely due to the complexity of the tax laws."
» indieOn Connects Music to the Blockchain
» 13 Music Label Sold to MTN
» Darcus Beese Named President Of Island Records
» ASCAP Revenues Top $1.144 Billion In 2017
» BMG Appoints New Creative Directors In Nashville
News Beat Directory
» [2018-09-16] Live Nation Electronic Asia Inks Deal With Budweiser For Creamfields Festivals; Together, Creamfields And Budweiser Will Focus On Building Entirely New Content For Dedicated Electronic Music Fans Throughout Asia
» [2018-08-23] Andy Ma Appointed Warner Music China CEO; Andy Ma Has Also Been Appointed EVP, Commercial And Business Development For Greater China
» [2018-08-23] IndieOn Connects Music To The Blockchain; IndieOn Is Confident Of Creating A "music Miner" Who Listens More And Grow Their Token Value
» [2018-06-23] The 2018 MIDEM Silk Road International Music Alliance Signing; International Music Industries Signing Of A Mutual Resource Sharing Agreement With Shanghai Conservatory Of Music & The China Records Group
» [2018-06-06] Screen Music Connect To Explore The Music Of Film, Television And Interactive Media; Created By James Hannigan, Award-winning Composer And Game Music Connect Co-founder, Screen Music Connect Builds On The Success Of The Sold-out Game Music Conferences
» [2018-06-05] Fred Casimir To Develop BMG's Global Recordings Business; As Well As Building BMG's European Infrastructure, Casimir Was Instrumental In Developing BMG's Recordings Business
» [2018-06-03] 13 Music Label Sold To MTN; DSN Music Spins Off Record Label To Albuquerque Music Entrepreneur's New Group
» [2018-06-02] CISAC 2018 Annual Report; A Comprehensive Overview Of The Confederation's Work To Serve 4 Million Creators And 239 Authors Societies Across The World
» [2018-06-02] MusicDish Announces A Love Electric 2018 China Tour; The Tour Will Crisscross Through China With 12 Shows In 8 Cities, Including Guangzhou, Dongguan, Zhuhai, Shenzhen, Kunming, Jiaxin, Wuhan And Beijing
» [2018-06-02] Darcus Beese Named President Of Island Records; Renowned U.K. Music Executive To Join Universal Music Group's U.S. Label Leadership
» [2018-05-17] Avant-Garde Label Maybe Noise Launches In Beijing; The Official Launch Will Be On May 26 At Magnet Theater With A Performance Supporting Its First Vinyl Release: Píng Zè
» [2018-05-04] Award-Winning Lithuanian Rock Band Colours Of Bubbles "She Is The Darkness" 2018 China Tour; The Tour Will Kickoff In Shanghai Where The Band Will Represent Lithuania During The Country's Signing To The Silk Road Music Alliance
follow MusicDish on