MusicDish e-Journal - April 19, 2018
MusicDish Advertising Network
Search MusicDish e-Journal (Advanced)
Subscribe To MusicDish e-Journal
About | Contact | Advertise | RSS | Submit Article | Submit News | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution
Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network

Is All File Sharing a Crime?
By Eric de Fontenay (Founder & Publisher)
(more articles from this author)
Comment | Email | Print | RSS

Amidst college students opting for 'slap-on-the-wrist' settlements from the RIAA and Michael Robertson's lamenting the "multiple attempts to limit consumers' rights via DRM (digital rights management) technology" since his tenure at ("These are schemes which add "big brother" restrictions to what you can do with your own music library"), I thought I'd share a short email exchange I had with Bruce Iglauer from Alligator Records.

The discussion was in response to my April 30th editorial "Music Industry Uses IM To Warn Pirates" where I wondered what are a "significant numbers of copyrighted songs," which would trigger copyright warning messages sent by the RIAA, was anyway: "Should we expect a friendly 'warning' for sharing 10 files? 50? 100? How about 50 files, but they're from just 4 albums? And who's to ensure that individuals are not harassed for exerting their fair use rights by overzealous copyright holders?"

Bruce - "You ask a good question. The law defines petty larceny and grand larceny. But both are crimes. How many files is too many? From a legal point of view, you can't be a little bit pregnant. All file sharing is illegal, which I think you would agree on.

"The law works by prosecuting blatant criminals and hoping the prosecutions will discourage petty criminals. That sometimes works and sometimes doesn't. Legally, all file sharers should be prosecuted. Practically, they won't. I suppose the answer is to start with the biggest you can find and work downwards until the message is clear. If it were up to me, I would prosecute some big ones and some small ones, just to make the legal point."

My follow up query - "If I understand you correctly, sharing my music files from my laptop here in Paris to my desktop in NY is a prosecutable act? What about music professionals that use p2p for professional purposes, such as a Jazz pianist researching various renditions of a specific standard?"

Bruce's repose - "Are you asking me if I think that if you possess a legitimate file, you should be able to send it to yourself? Yes, I'm fine with that, as long as you either paid for it or have it with the owner's permission. Of course, you could create an MP3 file, attach it to an email, and send it to yourself without making it available to anyone else."

"I suppose somebody could use p2p for some kind of research, though it seems a remarkably haphazard way to do that, as vs. for example going to the BMA and ASCAP web sites and searching for all recorded versions."

"So, do I think that 1% of p2p might be for legitimate use? Yes, and probably 1% of burglar tools are used by the police for people who are breaking into their own cars because they forgot their car keys. But possession of burglar tools is illegal even if you don't commit a burglary."

Related MusicDish e-Journal Articles:
Warning: mysql_numrows(): supplied argument is not a valid MySQL result resource in /home/virtual/site2/fst/var/www/html/mag/index.php3 on line 254

Related News from Mi2N:
» Drinker Biddle Announces Settlement In Record Industry Lawsuit Against 18-Year-Old Princeton University Student
» EFF On College Student Settlements

Home » News Beat » Is All File Sharing a Crime?
Email |Print |Comment |RSS

back | top

MusicDish Advertising Network

News Beat

» Launches Its First Live Musical Themed Content Series

» Warner Music Group Acquires Sodatone

» PPL and PRS for Music Launch Licensing Joint Venture

» Music Festivals And Conferences Pledge To Tackle Gender Inequality

» ICE and Facebook Reach Multi-Territory Music Licensing Agreement

News Beat Directory

» [2018-04-01] Launches Its First Live Musical Themed Content Series; You Need The Code Is's First Ever Live Stream Music Program Providing Users With 14 Hand-selected Independent Artists For Their Entertainment

» [2018-03-28] Warner Music Group Acquires Sodatone; Data Pioneers Choose Entrepreneurial Home For Industry-leading A&R Tool

» [2018-03-09] Round Hill Music And Zync Sign Madge To Joint Venture; JV Publishing Venture To Support And Expand Zync's Successful Rights Representation Business

» [2018-03-03] PPL And PRS For Music Launch Licensing Joint Venture; Licensing Of Music Played In Public Now Administered By New Leicester-based Joint Venture, PPL PRS Ltd

» [2018-02-27] Music Festivals And Conferences Pledge To Tackle Gender Inequality; Keychange Initiative Encourages Gender Balance In Music By End Of 2022

» [2018-02-21] Briony Turner And Alec Boateng Promoted To Co-Heads Of A&R, Atlantic Records UK; Turner And Boateng Will Oversee The Atlantic A&R Team, Joint Projects, As Well As Maintaining Their Own Artist Rosters

» [2018-02-21] ICE And Facebook Reach Multi-Territory Music Licensing Agreement; New Deal Will See Songwriters And Composers Remunerated

» [2018-02-20] B-Reel Named Top 10 Most Innovative Company In Music By Fast Company; Global Creative Agency Receives Honor For Its Award-Winning Gorillaz Campaign

» [2018-02-18] YG PLUS And Gracenote To Bring K-POP To Fans Around The World; Gracenote And YG PLUS To Make All K-POP Music More Searchable And Discoverable On Global And Regional Streaming Music Platforms And Services

» [2018-02-17] VNUE Inc. To Acquire Music Rights Startup Soundstr; VNUE Acquisition Aims To Ensure A Fairer Royalty System

» [2018-02-17] Is Podcasting The New Radio?; 25% Of Surveyed Americans Say They've Listened To A Podcast In The Past Month, Up From Less Than 10% In 2008

» [2018-02-01] Insomniac Announces Inaugural Electric Daisy Carnival China Set To Debut In Shanghai; China Marks EDC's Second Location On The Asian Continent
MusicDish Advertising Network

follow MusicDish on
Follow MusicDish on Twitter

Mi2N Music PR

Carys - A Different Kind Of Normal - Debut CD Release

Melvin Riley Of Ready For The World Celebrates 35 Years In The Music Business And The Re-launch Of His Solo Career And New Billing Title

Listen: Darquise Explores The Art Of The Beak Up In His Debut Single "I Say One"

Artist Matthew Schultz Releases "Promise For Keeps" Featuring Gyptian

Richie Sambora Returns To Ovation Guitars With Signature Double Neck Guitar Benefitting Youth Music Charity

FLOW Announce The Arrival Tour And IMA / ZMR Award Nominations

Joseph L Young Returns To His First Love, The Saxophone, In "Every Moment" Releasing March 30

Websites: Mi2N | MusicDish*China | MusicDish Network | MusicDishTV | Urban Music News Network
Services: Submit Article | Submit News | Submit Video | Artist Development | Premium PR Distribution

Copyright © 1997-2018 MusicDish LLC., all rights reserved.
About MusicDish e-Journal | Contact Us | Advertise | RSS | Internships